The Power Of Transformation – Review: Serge Lutens Tubéreuse Criminelle

It would be no exaggeration if I said that there was a time when I considered Tubéreuse Criminelle to be my arch enemy. It stood for everything I did not like. Tuberose – that note alone was enough, once upon an unenlightened time, to put me off, but to open with a healthy dose of mothballs on ice – well, that was it. This Serge Lutens creation was, in my humble opinion, just a sick fantasy of someone not heeding the old Guy Robert adage: First and foremost, a perfume should smell good.

Tubéreuse Criminelle was created by Christopher Sheldrake in 1999 and includes notes of tuberose, jasmine, orange blossom, hyacinth, nutmeg, clove, styrax, musk and vanilla.

Apply Tubéreuse Criminelle without any idea what you are in for and you are probably scarred for life. But apply with caution and an open mind and you are in for a treat.

The famous opening of Tubéreuse Criminelle is like nothing else you ever smelled inside a perfume bottle at least. A blast of menthol, a medicinal, icy and rubbery waft of utterly non-perfume like odor holds sway for a few minutes, before like silvery mists parting they start to recede and unveil a tuberose so proud and full and regal only Fracas can stand up to it (and maybe Carnal Flower).

Never, ever would I spray Tubéreuse Criminelle, but dabbed I have grown to LOVE it. Yes, love it. The magical transformation, the receding mists, the incredibly beautiul perfectly petaled flower underneath, is breathtaking. From ugly duckling to beautiful swan, from cold and damp night to bright morning sunshine, from winter to spring – the metaphors are manifold, but they all only barely manage to convey the sensation of change, of transformation, of becoming, of renewal.

Everytime I wear Tubéreuse Criminelle I can’t help but go through the same facial expressions: disgust at first, wonder next, a tentative smile, a full-blown grin.

Tubéreuse Criminelle is a work of genius and while it’ll never be a apply and go perfume for me (way too much action!), I relish to apply a bit in the evening and watch, or rather smell, the show unfold.

Tubéreuse Criminelle is pure entertainment for the olfactory inclined person.

Image source: fragrantica.com, melangeapothecary.blogspot.com, avidpaper.com
About these ads

About Olfactoria

I'm on a journey through the world of fragrance - come with me!
This entry was posted in Floral, Fragrance Reviews, Serge Lutens, Tuberose and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

55 Responses to The Power Of Transformation – Review: Serge Lutens Tubéreuse Criminelle

  1. Sandra says:

    Yay! You have grown to love it! One of my staples in summer. I even love the beginning so much that I spray it on.

  2. baconbiscuit212 says:

    What an exciting review! I am glad that you persevered because the rewards sound amazing. I will have to try this one myself, cautiously :-)

  3. shylotus says:

    Oh my gosh, Birgit! Just tonight I was spritzing it on before bedtime and was searching some blogs to see what my favorite writers thought of it. Read Victoria’s, then noticed you just wrote about it tonight!!
    I felt exactly the same. For a year I could not accept it. Would not wait for the dry-down to see…just to see how it changed. Finally, last month I saw the light. Now I crave it like I do certain chocolates or McDonald’s french fries! (Not a very good metaphor, I know…) Thanks for the review!!!
    Amy M.

    • Olfactoria says:

      That is an excellent metaphor, unfortunately now I crave McDonalds fries! ;)

      It is really worth the wait, isn’t it? Perfumes that yield their secret slowly are so rewarding!

  4. Undina says:

    Nope, not me (though a very convincing review I must say).

    I wonder what will happen first – I’ll change my mind about Shalimar, No. 5 or tuberose perfumes?

  5. Lady Jane Grey says:

    Well, imho Sheldrake is a Genius. BUT ! His creations more often than not are difficoult, not to say problematic. And TC is an entirely prohibited area for me. I mean, “tuberose, jasmine, orange blossom, hyacinth, nutmeg, clove” – only one of these could already send me unconscious, not to mention the whole collection of them (that would probably kill me, if being hit on an especially weak day).

  6. Ines says:

    Ha, ha!! There you go! :)
    You became a tuberose lover! I knew it would happen. :)
    In my opinion, it is really not possible not to love tuberose – it’s just a matter of time. ;)

  7. andreawilko says:

    I am with Undina, it sounds far too challenging for me to actively seek it out, if some were to fall in my lap I would cautiously give it a try but if it is in a league with Fracas then I will admit defeat and say (almost with confidence) that this is not for me, I will stick to my wimps version of Tuberose with my Le Labo creation. :-)

    • Olfactoria says:

      I totally understand, it is challenging for sure and I won’t ever own a bottle of TC, but it is a triumph to finally get it and I’m glad I did persevere.
      Le Labo Tubereuse is so happy and pretty, it suits you! :)

  8. Tara says:

    It’s so great that you were your usual committed self and didn’t give on this one. No doubt I wouldn’t get on with the “mothballs on ice” opening (great description!) but it sounds worth putting in thw work for the reward. I’d like to try it one day just for the experience. It such a notorious perfume with the perfect name too.

  9. Alexandra says:

    I do have a small sample of this and I am definitely still stuck in the ‘not heeding the Roudnitska’ stage, but never say never!

  10. “Pure entertainment for the olfactory inclined” captures it very well! :-)
    I have found that the more I wear it, the more I have come to enjoy the menthol blast which was so morbid and creepy, goth-like in the beginning. It just takes some getting used to it, but then the silkiness of this tuberose is sans pareil. Like you say, it’s up there in the reference tuberoses top5.

    BTW, if I may, I believe it was Guy Robert and not E.Roudnitska who coined the adage “un parfum doit sent bon” (a perfume should smell good).
    Reason I mention is because I kinda think Roudnitska had a “thing” for perfumes that didn’t smell all that good in some hidden segmentation of them (those rotten melons that make Diorella and Le Parfum de Therese so captivating, for instance) ;-)

    • Olfactoria says:

      Hi Elena,
      thank you for the correction, it was of course Guy Robert who said that (as Luca Turin says in the Guide), I must have been confused. :)

      Morbid, creepy and goth – that captures the opening indeed, but as you say, one gets used to almost everything. ;)

  11. arline says:

    I’ve been exploring tuberose oil, and blending it with other oils that I love. It is definitely an interesting oil. It has many valuable healing properties, in and of itself.

    To smell tuberose on its own, in concentrated form is a no bueno!!!! But diluted, and I mean a lot, it has been nice. Actually, I have to get it on my skin to appreciate it. I put about 1/16 of an ounce of tuberose into 1 ounce of fractionated coconut oil (that has no smell). After it is on my skin for about 15 minutes, it starts to smell beautiful. I have been layering the oils on my skin, because I am not sure what works with what.

    I have a negatively visceral reaction to mothball smell, even thinking about it tightens my stomach, I doubt I would be willing to persevere and hold out for the beauty of Tuberose criminelle. I will take your word for it, and appreciate your hard work. :)

  12. Suzanne says:

    It’s funny, I was just leaving a comment at Parfumieren last night about feeling clobbered by what I call a Ben-Gay note that ruins By Kilian’s Back-to-Black for me. And yet I absolutley love the mentolated opening of Tubereuse Criminelle … it’s wintry frost blasting me and then melting away to reveal that tuberose that is, as Helg describes it, so silky.

    I don’t know what accounts for the difference, why I could love menthol in one creation and hate it in another, but that’s what makes perfume a facinating art. Thrilled to hear that you have come around to tuberose. If such things were voted on, I’d vote it the most gorgeous and fascinating flower on earth! :D

    • Olfactoria says:

      I’m not sure what Ben-Gay is, but my husband tells me it is some kind of muscle-rub or something?
      Funny, I wore Back to Black yesterday evening, but I’ve never smelled any menthol in there, I will look out for it next time.

      I’ll vote for that too, I love the look of tuberose too, so pretty. I hope to get a real one under my nose soon.

  13. Zubi d'Nova / Melissa de Blok says:

    So beautifully written Birgit!

    (Another SL I might love thanks to you? Let’s see when I go on my next sniffing trip at the department store)

  14. Bee says:

    the moment I prefer TC: when it is hovering between the two phases, pity that doesn’t last long. The tuberose is of course beautiful on it’s own, but it is such much more rewarding if you go through the “wintergreen” path first

  15. cj says:

    I’ve only just come around to tuberose myself, having quite unexpectedly fallen head-over-heels in love with Carnal Flower. At my first sniff of it, back in February, I thought it was beautiful but sooo “not me”. Plus, I think the name made it even more intimidating. But I recently was playing perfume consultant to some friends at the Frederic Malle counter, and recommended CF to one friend, whose personality suited it perfectly. She received a generous spritz, which I smelled wafts of through the rest of the evening. It was sublime, absolutely luminous on a hot, humid summer night. That evening left me craving it for days afterwards, until I worked up the courage to try wearing my own sample. I’ve been wearing it for a week straight now (the tiniest spritzes from my sample, trying not to use it up to fast), and I’m still hungry for more. I’m interested to try more tuberose fragrances now, but based on what I’ve read about other examples, I have a feeling that CF might be “the one” tuberose for me. I love its freshness, and I don’t think I could handle any more drama. But, of course, never say never… You’ve certainly piqued my curiosity about this one!

  16. This was one of the few fragrances I sniffed (unexpectedly), and was so amazed I bought it there and then.
    I find the opening desperately addictive and I just wish it lasted longer.
    However, with regular wear, I find that the opening isn’t so sharp any more (I guess I’ve gotten used to it) and I’m always surprised when I first spray it and relatives or friends say “God that’s strong!”. Lovely lovely perfume, one of the best soliflores available IMO :)
    I’m glad you’ve warmed to it! :D

    • Olfactoria says:

      I was sure you’d love this one. From what I know about you, this is right up your alley. :) I’m glad I’ve warmed to it too, it is a fun ride with a huge reward at the end.

  17. laniersmith says:

    It sounds dangerous and wicked. And like the name says …a bit of a criminal. I am going to look for it next time I am out and about sniffing the airs and wares. I know it is not for me but after your story I just have to smell this bad boy.

  18. I am SO glad that you have learned to love Tubereuse Criminelle, it is one of the most beautiful and fascinating tuberose by far.

    Long gone are our evil scent twin days, however when it comes to TC I am definitely a sprayer, not a dabber :-P

  19. Eva S says:

    This is serendipity I think,I tried TC for the first time only yesterday! I sprayed it on, not too carefully and I almost had some trouble breathing for a while! A truly fascinating scent, I can see how it can become addictive. Don’t think I’ll ever get a FB but I will surely use up my sample.
    I think the conclusion is that I have definitely gotten over my tuberose-phobia, it’s just Fracas that’s still impossible!

  20. Lavanya says:

    *grins* I never thought I’d see the day that you’d say this..I’m so glad you finally love TC- she is gorgeous!

  21. Pingback: Monday Question – What Is Your Favorite White Floral? | Olfactoria's Travels

  22. Pingback: Hot Town, Summer in the City – The Candy Perfume Boy Summer Special at Perfume Lovers London | Olfactoria's Travels

  23. Pingback: Round And Glowing – Review: Editions de Parfums Frederic Malle Carnal Flower | Olfactoria's Travels

  24. Pingback: Tubereuse Criminelle by Serge Lutens | Scentsate

  25. Another marvellous review. I have not had the pleasure of sniffing this, but will repair that forthwith. Big fan of Tuberose. Had a photographer friend who wore it excessively. Gorgeous Italian lady with a big personality. For myself, I confess to having a liking for Lutens’ Five O Clock Au Gingembre (fabulous name)! And my friend likes Ambre Sultan.

    • Olfactoria says:

      TC is definitely suited for a big personality. Ambre Sultan is my husband’s favorite too.
      Let me know what you think of Tubereuse Criminelle once you’ve tried it, which surely will be an interesting experience. :)

  26. Pingback: The Candy Perfume Boy’s Summer Special – Perfume Lovers London, The Cavendish Club, London on Thursday 18th July 2013 | Olfactoria's Travels

  27. Pingback: That Smile – Review: Hiram Green Moon Bloom | Olfactoria's Travels

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s